Quote:
Originally Posted by Derfernet
But you seem to want this order:
wannabe comedian>>>>>>>>disagree with Yahtzee+nothing intelligent to say
|
No, not at all. I can't even work out how you worked that out from my posts. You can't just make up my position for me.
Alexander is trying to protect DNF by attacking Yahtzee for making a disparaging review. I.e. trying to discredit the review by attacking the reviewer. That's an ad hominem.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Derfernet
I assume you are attacking specifically the wannabe comedian comment because "nothing intelligent to say" is referring Yahtzee's opinions and arguments, not the person, and can not be an ad hominem in any order.
|
I didn't attack the "wannabe comedian" comment specifically anywhere. Show me where you think I did.