Forum Archive

Go Back   3D Realms Forums > 3D Realms Topics > Other Apogee/3D Realms Games > Prey
Blogs FAQ Community Calendar

Notices

 
 
Thread Tools
Old 06-26-2006, 06:20 AM   #41
SuperSaiyan4
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
The only thing I noticed and picked on was the hands as they are square and things that you killed or marked just dissappearing however everything else was amazing, I can see what you guys mean about the low res part but I was busy actually playing the game and getting into however as far as the concerns I raised go they didnt stop me from playing the game and finishing the demo twice!
SuperSaiyan4 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 06:40 AM   #42
Ferretwave333
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Doctor
Please do. I played the demo 2 times and didn't notice anything. I suppose it's because I value gameplay over graphics

(playing on medium quality, 1024*768, everything else max, no aa/af)
Could you post some pics of the game on medium, like textures up close? Thanks.
Ferretwave333 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 09:42 AM   #43
SuperSaiyan4
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Would nice to see an Ultra High option on the PC, Doom 3 had it which from High to Ultra high was hardly noticeable and needed a graphics card that didnt even exist at that time.

You can now get 1gb memory graphics cards amazing!
SuperSaiyan4 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 09:51 AM   #44
Gryph

Gryph's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
I just started playing through again to see this low quality textures and I just don't really see them. Everything looks good enough for me.
__________________
1Emulation: The Peoples' Emulation Site
I pity the fool! - Mr. T
Gryph is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 10:49 AM   #45
desmasic
Thumbs down Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Playing it on highest quality possible, at 1280x1024 (6800GS, using latest nvidia drivers) >>

I played it the third time today, most low quality textures are only visible on walls. In alien ship though, it's hard to notice such things.. usually (which is a good thing). Going to play it again now, I just love sniping those aliens :P

Low res textures are the first thing I notice in every game I play, mostly because they are ACTUALLY low res and are right in your face from the start:



Another one here >> (5 images limit)


EDIT: Prob should mention that except for aliens, tommy and his grandpa, all character models (humans) have crappy textures. Don't know why, cause main character looks very detailed in comparison.
Last edited by desmasic; 06-26-2006 at 10:54 AM.
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 11:22 AM   #46
Denz

Denz's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
The toilet wall is indeed not that high. Also the http://swat.samods.org/extras/galler...w_03_thumb.jpg .
__________________
crunchy superman said:
10 years and two complete restarts - that's either one very effective filter, or a whole lotta shit. :D
Denz is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 11:25 AM   #47
Needle

Needle's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Looks fine to me. There has yet to be a game where textures don't look blurry when your up close. I do have to agree that blurriness had a little renaissance lately with the upcoming of all that multi texturing mumbo jumbo. But this looks far from bad. In fact, it looks excellent. It's not less blurry than most other games. It's just more obvious due to a) bump maps and b) lack of detail maps.
Needle is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 11:45 AM   #48
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Needle
Looks fine to me. There has yet to be a game where textures don't look blurry when your up close. I do have to agree that blurriness had a little renaissance lately with the upcoming of all that multi texturing mumbo jumbo. But this looks far from bad. In fact, it looks excellent. It's not less blurry than most other games. It's just more obvious due to a) bump maps and b) lack of detail maps.

Bump mapping.. parallax mapping (here) makes it look better and is the only saviour. If you have played HL2 (perfect example), then you will see what majority of areas without local and specular maps does to the environment (it looks unrealistic even for a fictional environment).

BTW, those shots were taken at medium distance, not at extreme closeups, at extreme close ups you can hardly see any detail in any game out there. Oh and first shots are taken right from the opening cinematic, so unless the developers want people to never walk near any wall, I think most of us will notice the quality.. A LOT!
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:07 PM   #49
Needle

Needle's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
So you think HL2 looks bad too eh? Maybe you should stop playing games all together. The hardware to make them "look good" obviously doesn't exist yet.
Needle is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:13 PM   #50
nerull7
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Whats about that machine on the third picture above? In game you can turn it on/off. Is there some secret connected to it?
nerull7 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:35 PM   #51
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Needle
So you think HL2 looks bad too eh? Maybe you should stop playing games all together. The hardware to make them "look good" obviously doesn't exist yet.

Yeah, it's called 'high res' textures, and it's not a hardware


@nerull7
Doesn't do anything for me.



EDIT: BTW, I just wanna make it clear that though I don't enjoy the low res textures, Prey is still more fun with or without them, and I am looking forward to this game. It's just that I am a real pain in the ass when it comes to noticing things like texture or models quality in every game I play :P
Last edited by desmasic; 06-26-2006 at 12:50 PM.
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:42 PM   #52
0marTheZealot
 
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Desmasic's pictures are perfect examples. Those textures jut right out and smack you in the face. They seriously look out of place for a game in 2006.
0marTheZealot is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:52 PM   #53
Zizz

Zizz's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by desmasic
Playing it on highest quality possible, at 1280x1024 (6800GS, using latest nvidia drivers) >>
Another one here >> (5 images limit)

This aint the texture quality. Its obivously overscaled. they seem to do that quiet often, scale textures in the editor.

I dont see what people are crying about. The game has awsome looking, high quality textures everywhere...maybe not so in the firtst 5 minutes (aka bar scene) tough they make a good atmosphere...but seriously, why would you make a deal out of it? they wont change them now...
__________________
Hot d3 mod!
Zizz is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:56 PM   #54
Talos

Talos's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
omg I can't hear it anymore...
Seriously it's not all about uber highres textures in EVERY place of the game!!!
(nearly) everyone in here is bitchin about low res textures, but how about you point out the pros of the games textures like the most organic surfaces EVER seen in any game to date!!
I for one love the textures and after all it's the ensamble that counts and Prey offers a cohesive game experience where the look and feel fits perfectly the desired overwhelming experience of being drawn into a hostile alien environment.
There are few games out there (especially in the shooter market) which made me go wow - But Prey made my mouth dry out.

Kudos to Human Head and 3DRealms!
Talos is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 12:59 PM   #55
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
^ Well that won't be a very good thing. Unless you are using TNT2 Ultra, you should expect high quality from games you play. Have you even seen how big the textures actually are in the demo?

They obviously have scaled the textures, but scaling a 256x256 texture for a whole wall isn't very pretty. Try doing same with 1024x1024 in D3 engine, looks damn detailed even at close range. I am talking about Ultra quality in Quake4 and Doom3 btw, pure TGA goodness

Can anyone from 3D Realms staff confirm that the low quality was just for the demo and we can expect higher quality textures in full version? I mean we are talking PC here, not Xbox.
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:01 PM   #56
Sebastian

Sebastian's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Highest quality textures in full game are going to require 512mb graphiccard so Highest quality textures for me!
Sebastian is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:12 PM   #57
Talos

Talos's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by desmasic
Can anyone from 3D Realms staff confirm that the low quality was just for the demo and we can expect higher quality textures in full version? I mean we are talking PC here, not Xbox.
low quality... oh man that is embarrassing
Talos is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:13 PM   #58
Oblivion
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Although I agree Desmasic about the textures. And I even noticed the human models. I must say that this game brought me a ton of joy. AND THAT'S ONLY A DEMO! It was insane how much I loved this while only playing a demo. I never even paid attention to Prey because I'm a huge Duke Nukem fan. So I always kept heading right for the DNF areas. I could have cared less if this thing looked like half life 1 it was so fun. My biggest visual complaint about the game is a hand-me-down from using the Doom3 engine. Everything is more shiny that it should be. I dislike all the shiny. It's a nice way to create a type of illusion that makes it look nicer than it really is, but I still would prefer less reflectivitey, and more dirt. The whole gravity switching thing is incredible. Multiplayer is a lot of fun, but I feel it suffers from the doom3 engine. I can't put my finger on it exactly, but I think it has something to do with the character movement speed... it just feels wrong. I won't say it's too slow, but... it lacks variation I suppose. I'm deeply impressed by the amount of effort that must have been put into making maps for this game. You guys have some very talented people working there. The gameplay in Prey sold me, which is why it'll have my money and make me a happy gamer. I'm on a 2 year old computer and it runs Prey great in almost max settings. This is kind of dissapointing, but I understand the reasons. No I'm not insane, I just like it when I see games that make me want to upgrade my computer. A bit of advice about interactivitey in games though... in the begining of Prey there are lots of things to mess with in the bar. This was great. BUT if you only do this in the begining area, it makes people wonder why you bothered? Granted this wasn't much of the game in the demo, but it seems you did it to impress people in the begining then let it die. Once you're on the ship, the only interactive things became monitors, and only specific ones. I hope to see more interactive objects later in the game, even ones that serve no purpose (like the water heater shown in one of the pictures above). Either do something and stick with it, or don't do it. It wouldn't have changed gameplay one bit if I couldn't have flushed the toilet, turned the sinks on, lifted the seats, ect. So if you took it out it wouldn't be a bad thing. Personally I love that stuff and want to see more in the future. But you shouldn't say, "we'll give you a little now, but no more later." Everything feels more stationary when you do that. But just like the other guys complaining about little things on here, I will still be getting this game because it's amazing. Fortunately 3DR isn't composed of idiots, so they already know we're all getting this game no matter how much we might complain about small things, because in the end they're just that: small.
Oblivion is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:41 PM   #59
Micki!

Micki!'s Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by desmasic
Yeah, it's called 'high res' textures, and it's not a hardware
You misunderstood his point...

He's saying, there doesn't exist hardware (enough good videocards etc) to make a demanding game like Prey, to run high textures...

Now, They COULD make higher resolutions, but that would make the game run like crap on almost any system... Only top notch machines will be acle to enjoy full graphics...
And not everyone is going to buy new hardware, in the following 1-2 years (or even longer)

I think they optimized the game greatly, making it both look great, and play smoothly...

Anyways, i'm glad you enjoy the actualy game though... I'd be surprised if you didn't...
__________________
A true genius does not need boundaries such as 'common sense'
Micki! is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:50 PM   #60
avatar_58

avatar_58's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
I thought the bumpmaps on this game were used enough to hide any low-res texture work, and some of the more 'blurry' textures are used in areas where it doesn't make much difference. The bathroom wall for example looks fine to me, because what difference would seeing more ripples make? Its still a smooth wall so I'd rather they didn't waste performance, and instead spend it on the tiles and other textures (which they did).

In general I do agree games need higher resolution textures, however NOT at the cost of polygons or bumpmapping because to me that looks equally as bad. Seeing a 1024x768 texture on a flat wall is just as bad as a super low quality 320 texture on a hevaily bump mapped surface. Some areas of HL2 had amazing textures, but the walls themselves were flat and lifeless.....that hurts the image to me.

I do think there is a happy medium, but for now Prey looks excellent enough for me. Especially with that new "High resolution bump mapping" feature that makes cracks and details look much better.
avatar_58 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 01:57 PM   #61
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Micki!
Now, They COULD make higher resolutions, but that would make the game run like crap on almost any system... Only top notch machines will be acle to enjoy full graphics...
And not everyone is going to buy new hardware, in the following 1-2 years (or even longer)

Ok, here's the thing. People running at low quality will run the game at low quality. People with hardware good enough to run the game at higher quality will 'choose' higher quality from options and will enjoy more detail. Nothing changes. People with slow machines still get the same quality you got from the demo, and people with high machines get better quality.

So you are forgetting that people can 'optimize' (options ie.) the game according to their machines. Adding high res textures means that higher quality unlocks more details. Lower quality setting will still use low res DDS textures. So it doesn't change anything anywhere. Everyone is happy.

Right now it looks like there ARE NO high res/quality textures AT ALL even Highest quality. It's prob just cause of demo, but they should confirm this if possible, cause Prey's medium Quality was supposed to be equal to Doom3's highest quality level, and what I saw was Doom3's lowest quality level in most textures.



Oh and you are right about the gameplay. It's fun and innovative
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 02:26 PM   #62
Needle

Needle's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Dude, don't you think if it would possible with current hardware to stick multiple super-hires texutres to every single surface, they would do it? I mean, why shouldn't they? Because they're lazy? Or maybe solely to piss you off?
Needle is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 02:31 PM   #63
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Needle
Dude, don't you think if it would possible with current hardware to stick multiple super-hires texutres to every single surface, they would do it? I mean, why shouldn't they? Because they're lazy? Or maybe solely to piss you off?
I think you're more pissed off than me

And yes, they can do it, it's possible (in D3). If they can't, prob the limitation with some features they used in exchange for texture quality (to increase performance) or prob cause it is pure D3 code they worked on, when Doom3 wasn't even out.
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 02:36 PM   #64
0marTheZealot
 
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
The fact is that games that came out in 2003/2004 had much higher texture resolution than Prey does. FarCry, HL2, Chronicles of Riddick, Guild Wars all have much better looking textures than Prey does. It doesn't hurt gameplay, but it's kind of annoying that in 2006, a triple A game has blurry textures at a medium or even far distance. While Prey stills pretty good, it also comes out as a bit "moddy" instead of full blown professionality.

The problem is that to people like me and desmasic, is that these textures leap out at hit you in the face. We didn't go looking for bad textures (at least I didn't), we just noticed them during the course of our playing experience.
0marTheZealot is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 04:03 PM   #65
brandon105
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
None of those games had better textures....are you blind?...go replay them and look for yourself, HL2 textures are grey and dule and remind me of HL1 not all of the textures atleast, not to bash half like 2, Far Cry looked good, but still had bad textures here and there, chronicles of riddick had the samn problem as Half Life 2..Guild Wars is a 3rd person game...try playing that in first person it will look worse then all them and the bloom lighting hides most of their blurryness. I hate games that try so hard to look realistic and fail, im more a cartoony stylized person when it comes to games, I like graphics like WoW and Banjo Kazooie and lots of colors...go figure, but it is indeed a game and the graphics are the best out atm imo, trust me on it. And yes Prey does have a few blurry areas...but what game doesn't?, if it looked to good no one could run it.

It also shows that these people who made this game weren't out for money but to make a very playable game, one that you can play over and over, I can tell you this from the demo.
If they were out for money, they would make it look like Jesus, then release it without a lengthy demo and they would sell like hotcakes on their graphics alone.
Last edited by brandon105; 06-26-2006 at 04:36 PM.
brandon105 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 04:39 PM   #66
desmasic
Irritated Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by brandon105
..I like graphics like WoW and Banjo Kazooie and lots of colors...go figure, but it is indeed a game and the graphics are the best out atm imo, trust me on it.
This coming from a guy who thinks all the best games out there have crappy 'graphics' (even though we are talking about just textures) compared to Prey.. and thinks WOW and Banjo looks better than FarCry and HL2.

Not to mention the fact that you just want us to believe that 3DR doesn't want our money and is a charitable organization, and you think that the demo sucks >>

Quote:
Originally Posted by brandon105
It also shows that these people who made this game weren't out for money but to make a very playable game, one that you can play over and over, I can tell you this from the demo.
If they were out for money, they would make it look like Jesus, then release it without a lengthy demo and they would sell like hotcakes on their graphics alone.

Please send us whatever you are smoking. (Edit: Ok, don't)


BTW, have you tried SHOGO, brandon? I heard it has some nice next gen graphics and models, you'll love it.
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 04:40 PM   #67
ercdevious
Guest
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
God forbid they keep you from looking at the bathroom walls in high resolution..
 
Old 06-26-2006, 05:39 PM   #68
brandon105
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
Quote:
Originally Posted by desmasic
This coming from a guy who thinks all the best games out there have crappy 'graphics' (even though we are talking about just textures) compared to Prey.. and thinks WOW and Banjo looks better than FarCry and HL2.

Not to mention the fact that you just want us to believe that 3DR doesn't want our money and is a charitable organization, and you think that the demo sucks >>




Please send us whatever you are smoking. (Edit: Ok, don't)


BTW, have you tried SHOGO, brandon? I heard it has some nice next gen graphics and models, you'll love it.






Um...I didn't say the demo sucked, I said I loved it....wtf are YOU smoking....I didn't say WoW has better "graphics" either...I said I like the style of stylized art instead of no colors at all. sigh
brandon105 is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 05:46 PM   #69
desmasic
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
You should still try SHOGO. *sigh*
desmasic is offline  
Old 06-26-2006, 05:58 PM   #70
George Broussard

George Broussard's Avatar
Re: 'High' Quality in full version (PC)..
desmasic,

You've made your point, really. If you don't like compressed textures then don't buy/play the game.

No need to try and 'win' and convince everyone on the Internet.

FYI, pretty much every FPS I know in the last couple of years ships with compressed textures.
George Broussard is offline  
 

Bookmarks


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:03 PM.

Page generated in 0.15782905 seconds (100.00% PHP - 0% MySQL) with 16 queries

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.

Website is ©1987-2014 Apogee Software, Ltd.
Ideas and messages posted here become property of Apogee Software Ltd.